Here’s a confession. Of all the movies I saw last year, the only one I wanted to see again, the only one whose scenes kept playing in my head weeks after I saw it, was The Town. Not Banksy’s Exit Through the Gift Shop, not Joon-ho Bong’s Mother, not Luca Guadagnino’s I Am Love, but Ben Affleck’s The Town. This, even though the film, which grossed over $100 million, feeds liberally off of genre clichés: action sequences juiced with quick jump-cuts, a sensitive thug trying to make good, a star-crossed romance, two sex scenes, a wistful, though satisfying, climax. I’m hard-pressed to name anything fresh or original in The Town. And yet when it came out on Netflix I eagerly sent it to the front of my queue.
The film follows the fortunes of a Boston bank-robbing crew led by Ben Affleck and Jeremy Renner. During the heist that opens the film, a bank manager, played by Rebecca Hall, catches a glimpse of Renner. The next week, Affleck tails her to make sure she doesn’t give them away to the Feds. The obvious ensues. He falls in love with her, she with him, and the problem of how he’s going to reveal who he really is slowly makes its way toward resolution.
The performances in The Town require no defense. Affleck, who also co-wrote the film, milks rich drama out of confrontation scenes, especially those featuring Hall and Renner (who ended up getting an Oscar nomination for Best Supporting Actor). There’s also a spectacular scene in which Pete Postlethwaite, a menacing florist who also plans the crew’s heists, puts the kibosh on Affleck’s decision to leave the crew. (I immediately jumped to it when I got the DVD from Netflix.) As the film’s lead, Affleck pulls off the sensitive thug bit with finesse, waxing emotional with a Southie accent and stalking A.A. meetings with wounded eyes while periodically putting beatdowns on old acquaintances from the ‘hood and showing off his ‘roided, tatted shoulders.
It may be a high-quality genre film, but a genre film it certainly is. One of the big distinctions between a genre narrative and a literary narrative is that the former evokes an unrecognizable world; that is to say, it evokes a world that doesn’t impose the same curbs on the characters (bank thieves can breach a citywide police gauntlet) or exact the same consequences (the thieves’ liberal use of assault rifles never seems to harm any police or bystanders). It’s a world with no semblance of the workaday, a world of highlights rather than minutiae.
Ultimately, the genre film is a fantasia, the kind of film that does requires no suspension of disbelief because it was never believable to begin with. The most unbelievable thing in The Town is that Ben Affleck’s character retains his emotional sensitivity even as he’s knocking off banks and shooting at cops. In the real world, to do the latter stuff requires renunciation of the former; to keep the former requires abstinence from the latter. No one gets to have it both ways, which is why The Town, for all of its fun drama, remains steadfastly a genre film.
And it’s also the reason I wanted to see it again. For me, the excitement of the film is not in the action, or even the ingenuity of the heists; it’s in watching a character have it both ways, be both a daring transgressor and a self-reflecting citizen, a badass thug and a young man vulnerably in love. Schmucks like me can’t be both. Projecting myself onto Ben Affleck’s character in The Town is the closest I’ll get to unleashing my repressed sociopath. Far less fun it is to identify with Tilda Swinton in I Am Love, who must make a painful decision between passion and family in a world that often does not allow both. That film is brilliant, but where’s the joy in seeing renunciation occur on screen? For sheer gratification, I want to watch the character who doesn’t have to give up anything.